Tuesday, March 30, 2010

"Masculinity Stereotype"

As our class discussed the role of masculinity in society, I became intrigued as to why a society would tolerate and even condone the stereotypical role of masculinity, as portrayed by the media. As such, I decided to discuss and shed some light on a few stereotypes of masculinity.
First, why can’t we grow up untainted by society’s perception of “masculinity?” It seems apparent that we start gender assignment before a person is even born, buying pink things for girls and blue things for boys. It escalates from here as children begin to develop and starts to get mobile. After a little boy falls down, it is common for parents to respond, “Stop crying, suck it up, or you’re a big boy,” whereas a girl is allowed to cry, while being offered comfort, because shedding tears is accepted as a feminine trait. Henceforth, if a boy cries he is acting like a “girl,” because this is a learned accepted fact given to him by society. Oddly enough, I have heard many times that women are more capable of sustaining higher pain thresholds than men, due to their physiology. I don’t know if there is truth in that, but from what I have witnessed in my own life, I would stand behind that statement. However, in order for men to be men, they must be “tough,” they must endure painful situations without the slightest utterance, and not give way to tears of emotion, or else they are not considered masculine.
Secondly, I’d like to discuss the term “man’s work.” Throughout our lives, the idea is impressed upon us that men do certain types of work and women do other types of work. For instance, it is acceptable for a man to work on a car but not for a woman. Such labor is accepted as man’s work, but why? What makes a man more capable of working on a car than a woman? While some would argue that physical strength makes a man better equipped for such work. The tools and equipment available today make it easy for almost anyone to change a tire, oil, or an engine! As such, “man’s work” is a stereotype, repeatedly enforced by media.
The real question remains, what can we do to stop this gender assignment, given to us by the media, and advertisers? My proposal is to become familiar with such “assignments” and become proactive at stomping them out. Next, we must teach our children not to accept such assignments, but to live true to their dreams and passions. In this way, we can pass on less stereotypical views to the next generation. If a boy cries when he gets hurt, let it be. Don’t enforce the stereotypes of masculinity. But, instead work with people, and especially children, recognizing them for their strengths, weaknesses, talents, and interests, rather than specific gender traits.

3 comments:

  1. Interesting post. I agree that kids are pushed and rewarded for acting like a "boy" or a "girl". One thing you didn't mention, but could be tied to the "suck it up and don't cry" mentality/training is it seems a lot of men have a very hard time getting in touch with their emotional side. From my experience they seem to want to "fix" the problem for the sake of fixing without getting into the emotional piece of why something is an issue.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The majority of the scientific evidence shows that children learn gender stereotypes from adults. Socializing agents such as parents, teachers, peers, religious leaders, and media pass along gender stereotypes from one generation to the next. While most people feel as though gender stereotypes are mostly negative, I thought I'd look into some positive outcomes that come from gender stereotyping since there are always two sides to every story.

    Gender stereotyping can be a normal cognitive process that allows children to form categories based on gender and to understand this attribute in a simple way. This can be positive because children have limits on their cognitive abilities due to their still developing brains. They need simplistic categories so they can understand streamline life and how they can interact with the complex world. Children do not have the mental capacity to think intuitively and abstractly about views of gender because they are in the pre-operational stage of cognitive development, according to Piaget. In addition, gender stereotyping during childhood does not necessarily mean that as an adult they while continue to maintain these stereotypes. Research shows that older children, adolescents, and adults become more flexible with their use of stereotypes and can make exceptions to stereotypes both for themselves and others.
    There is a theory called the "kernel of truth" which holds the position that stereotypes have some validity to them. There are certainly different social roles that men and women have filled for hundreds and hundreds of years while living together. These gender roles are sets of behaviors that are typical and can lead to the formation of gender stereotypes. Due to our anatomy, women give birth to children and have inherent child rearing skills. Men are
    physiologically built more masculine and are therefore inherently protectors. These social roles have not changed drastically over the years and therefore lead to stereotypes. But, regardless of
    overestimations and underestimations of gender roles, these roles have led to generation after generation of people.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm leaning towards Amanda's opinion on this one. As much as I agree with you about pushing young kids in to a role of masculinity and femininity too early, there is a valid reason why we are given certain roles in society. Men and women have had different roles in society for generation. Instinctively men are hunters and gatherers and women are nurturers. It used to be and still is in most societies men are protectors of their family. Why? Because men are physically stronger and more aggresive than the female. Not that without a man a woman would let harm befall on her and her children. And yes there are some things I personally would expect my man to do such as changing the bulbs around the house, mowing the lawn, plumbing, picking up heavy merchandise... the list long. Otherwise what's the use of having him around. I'm sure those of you who disagree have been conditioned otherwise. Thats how its been with my family and my husband's family and most families as a matter of fact.
    I'm a mother and when it comes to my son I treat him like I would treat a child not a boy that needs to suck up the pain or agony. I let him talk cry and talk it out. My husband on the other hand is the one that tells him to suck it up. To some degree I'm ok wit that because there is an equilibrium. My son learns that there are some things he can tolerate and handle it himself and if it really hurt then mommy and daddy arms are wide open. If I had a girl I know my husband would probably treat her gently and so would I, but I probably would be a little harder on her than my husband would.
    We may change a few things about the roles, but the rest are set, and for our own good and society

    ReplyDelete