Tuesday, September 29, 2009

Surveillance

Since 9/11 we've seen the passing of the Patriot Act as lead to many erosions of rights. The ACLU has a webpage devoted to explaining which of our rights have been violated by the Act. Remember the Fourth Amendment? It's gone. The Patriot Act gives the FBI the ability to monitor you in every way without probable cause of a crime. Since then there has been over 1 million United States citizens added to the terrorist watch list.
The problem with this is these methods to not stop an attack from happening. If one does, we should expect to see more surveillance, more wiretapping, and so on. This cause and affect relationship is happening with regards to crime. Every year our government puts more police on the roads, and more people in prison, with little affect on crime. So the next year, they build more prisons, put more people in jail, and make the punishments for crime greater, but to no avail. Currently, there are more people in jail in the USA than in any other country in the world. As a response the police become more totalitarian. They must, because to them what they were doing last year wasn't working so they must be stricter.
The UK is quickly becoming a big brother country, with more CCTV cameras than anywhere else. And yet last year the chief of police admitted that they haven't deterred crime. The agencies there also monitor phone calls, and there are programs in the works to record all traffic from everyone's computers to create profiles of the citizens. This is being done not to deter a terrorist threat, but to keep better control of their system. And the people are compliant, out of fear. Their goal is to keep the system the way it is, to stop change. I've read articles about activists being arrested in masse for simply planning to protest. They were under arrest for suspicion of something or other.
The problem is surveillance on our own citizens will be vastly ineffective at combating crime or terrorism. As it gets worse they will increase these measures. The fear I have is that there may come a day when you cannot talk on the phone or internet and say something angrily about the government, a politician, or the country itself without having a knock at the door and asked to be interrogated. This is a free country we must be able to speak out against what we don't like, even in the extreme it is our right to question authority. Great change in this country has happened because of this ability. Imagine before we gained our independence that England had surveillance technologies that were able to keep track of the founding fathers phone calls, and cameras on the street corners. Our revolution would have been squashed from the get go, even if it was beneficial to the people, it would not have been to the government of England and it would have been stopped immediately. There have been many times that change has occurred in this country that wasn't in the best interest of the government but in the best interests of the people. With a vast surveillance system at that time, change may never have occurred!
The little protection Surveillance may bring to terrorism is not worth what it can take away from the people. We must be able to share radical ideas, we must be able to question the government without fear. We must maintain the ability to congregate for social change. There may be a time when the people want change but not the government, we will need our rights.

Benjamin Franklin a founding father that signed both the Constitution and the Declaration of Indepence once said: "Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety."

2 comments:

  1. I freaking agree. I feel that its a bunch of crap. Its an excuse to track monitor and be fucking nosey. The government wants to be in control of everything because they will generated more money. If you look @ washington dc for instance because of the new survellence cameras on the streets they have generated over 1 million profit in tickets. So where the hell is the $$$$... going. In every case money is generated out of these programs so is the behind sences reason to really stop terriorts. maybe to an exstant but in reality it gives the government a reason to be nosey. By locking up more criminals it gives lawyers and the judicial system millions of dollars a year from fines, probation fees, and urine tests. Also by stopping protesters and locking them up also generates more income for the bails they have to pay which again the government is the ones recieing money and we gret to make no change in what we believe in again bullshit!!!!!! So where is the freedom of speech the fucking freedom period. We have no voice because its being controled and the only think we do have that is freedom is our will and thoughts which scientists are trying to figure a way out to find out our thoughts as well . Pretty soon we will be stamped with barcodes at birth to control us period.... Thats a damn shame.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really don’t care if the government is listening to me on the phone. I know I’m not a terrorist and it doesn’t bother me that the government wants to protect our country. Ever since 9/11 the government has done an excellent job in doing so and I think they should continue to. I can still go about my life. Also, when complaining about the government taking our money for dumb things, I think that we all need to stop being such big babies and realize that they are just doing their job. Maybe we shouldn’t have elected such a dumb president in the first place because my parents make good money and need to sign off a certain portion to people who don’t, which is just ridiculous, but thats the way it is.

    ReplyDelete